The Most Consistent Premier League Clubs of the Last 20 Year

Consistency in the Premier League is a rare and undervalued currency. While trophies and big signings grab headlines, sustained performance across two decades reveals more about a club’s foundation, management, and long-term vision. Looking back at the last 20 years, a handful of clubs have stood apart by maintaining top-flight status, regularly qualifying for European competitions, and finishing high in the league more often than not. Here’s a closer look at the Premier League’s most consistent sides since the 2004–05 season.

1. Manchester City

Seasons in Premier League (2004–24): 20
Average League Finish: 3.9
Titles Won: 8
Lowest Finish: 15th (2006–07)

Manchester City’s transformation under Sheikh Mansour’s ownership in 2008 turned a mid-table club into a dominant force. Since 2011–12, they have finished in the top four every season. Pep Guardiola’s arrival in 2016 marked the beginning of sustained tactical evolution and consistent league dominance, with multiple title wins and records broken.

2. Chelsea

Seasons in Premier League (2004–24): 20
Average League Finish: 4.5
Titles Won: 5
Lowest Finish: 12th (2022–23)

Chelsea entered the modern era with the financial backing of Roman Abramovich, winning titles under José Mourinho and maintaining a high standard throughout the 2010s. Despite recent managerial instability and inconsistent form post-2021, they’ve consistently qualified for Europe and lifted both domestic and European silverware.

3. Manchester United

Seasons in Premier League (2004–24): 20
Average League Finish: 4.6
Titles Won: 5
Lowest Finish: 8th (2013–14, 2023–24)

United’s early years under Sir Alex Ferguson in this period were dominant. However, post-2013 has seen turbulence. Despite the managerial merry-go-round and inconsistent squad builds, United have remained a constant in the top six and regularly featured in Europe.

4. Arsenal

Seasons in Premier League (2004–24): 20
Average League Finish: 4.8
Titles Won: 0
Lowest Finish: 8th (2019–20, 2020–21)

Though trophyless in the league during this period, Arsenal’s ability to stay within the top four under Arsène Wenger was unmatched during the 2000s. Even after a dip in form during the late 2010s, the club has rebounded strongly under Mikel Arteta, returning to title contention.

5. Liverpool

Seasons in Premier League (2004–24): 20
Average League Finish: 4.9
Titles Won: 2
Lowest Finish: 8th (2011–12)

Liverpool’s resurgence under Jürgen Klopp after years of underachievement has been remarkable. A Champions League triumph and a long-awaited Premier League title arrived alongside several top-two finishes. They’ve become one of the most tactically coherent and physically relentless sides in Europe.

6. Tottenham Hotspur

Seasons in Premier League (2004–24): 20
Average League Finish: 6.2
Titles Won: 0
Lowest Finish: 11th (2008–09)

Though they haven’t clinched the league, Spurs have evolved from a mid-table team to a regular European contender. The Mauricio Pochettino era brought stability and Champions League qualification, and they have consistently finished in the top six, barring a few stumbles.

7. Aston Villa

Seasons in Premier League (2004–24): 18
Average League Finish: 11.3
Titles Won: 0
Lowest Finish: 17th (2014–15)
Relegated: 2015–16

Villa’s consistency was disrupted by relegation in 2016, but their presence in the league for most of the last two decades and recent rise under Unai Emery warrants inclusion. They’ve returned to Europe and look set to become a mainstay in the upper half again.

8. Everton

Seasons in Premier League (2004–24): 20
Average League Finish: 10.2
Titles Won: 0
Lowest Finish: 17th (2021–22, 2022–23)

Everton haven’t been relegated in the Premier League era and spent much of the 2000s pushing for Europe under David Moyes. Although recent seasons have seen them slide into relegation battles, their long-term stability and top-flight status are notable.

The Benchmark of Consistency

Consistency isn’t just about finishing top; it’s about maintaining a standard despite ownership changes, financial swings, and generational turnover. Clubs like Manchester City and Chelsea have redefined success, while sides like Tottenham and Arsenal have shown the value of long-term strategy, even without league titles.

The Premier League may be unpredictable on the surface, but over the past 20 years, a core group of clubs has proven they can withstand the chaos and remain competitive year in, year out.

Source